Efforts to pass physician-assisted dying legislation in the Aloha state date back to the late 1990s.
A physician-assisted dying bill was considered in the 1998, 1999, and 2001 Hawai‘i legislative sessions.
Governor Benjamin J. Cayetano, a long-time supporter of the issue, sponsored House Bill 2487, the Hawai‘i Death with Dignity Act, which was closely modeled after the Oregon law (the companion bill in the Senate was SB 2745). The bill was authored by our founding board member, Eli Stutsman, JD, and supported by numerous local and national organizations including Hawaii Advocates for Consumer Rights, American Civil Liberties Union of Hawai‘i, and the First Unitarian Church of Honolulu. At the time, 72 percent of Hawai‘i residents supported the legislation.
The bill passed the House Judiciary Committee 10 to 1, with 3 abstentions, and on the House floor 30 to 20. Following some legislative wrangling and eventual success in the Senate Judiciary Committee, the bill moved to the full Senate. Due in large part to a strong organizing and lobbying effort by the religious opposition, the bill fell short of passage in the Senate by mere two votes, 14 to 11.
Until this time, no death-with-dignity proposal had come within striking distance of success in a state legislature.
Death with Dignity’s predecessor organization provided substantial financial, strategic, legal, and political resources to conduct the near-winning campaign, while maintaining a supporting role to the local Hawai‘i organization.
A new physician-assisted dying bill, HB 862/SB 391, failed to advance out of Committee despite a new poll showing that 71 percent of state residents supported it.
Following the 2002 and 2003 defeats, support for the issue around the states eroded. However, half a dozen veteran Hawai‘i advocates sensed the need for a hands-on local organizing and coordinating effort. The result of their considerations was the founding of Hawai‘i Death with Dignity Society in December.
A pair of companion bills, HB 1454/SB 1308, was again considered but failed to advance.
The all volunteer group Hawai‘i Death with Dignity Society attempted to get an aid-in-dying bill passed (HB 675/SB 800, SB 1995) with no success.
House Bill 806, sponsored by Representatives Oshiro (D), Belatti (D), Karamatsu (D), Marumoto (R), Say (D), Thielen (R), and Bertram (D), was referred to the House Judiciary Committee and carried over to the 2010 session with no action.
Compassion & Choices, the other mainland right-to-die organization, forcefully declared that Death with Dignity was already legal in the state, basing their argument upon a little-known 1909 Hawai‘i territorial law. Shortly thereafter, the Hawai‘i Attorney General stepped-in, issuing an opinion that writing prescriptions to hasten a competent adult’s impending death was still unlawful in Hawai‘i, meaning that that such activity was still a crime and would be prosecuted as such. The organization was forced to withdraw from the state.
The Hawai‘i Death with Dignity Society again tried to get a bill passed; House Bill 606 did not move out of Committee.
2015 to present
In 2015, another bill was introduced in the Hawai‘i House, by Representative Ito (D). HB 1255 did not move forward but was carried over to 2016 and failed to meet a Committee deadline for a hearing. The companion Senate Bill 2373, Hawai‘i Death with Dignity Act, introduced by Senators Lorraine Inouye (D-District 4), Donovan Dela Cruz (D-District 22), Russell Ruderman (D-District 2), Brickwood Galuteria (D-District 12), and Glenn Wakai (D-District 15) on January 22, 2016, was referred to the Committee on Commerce, Consumer Protection, and Health and the Committee on Judiciary and Labor, and also failed to meet a deadline for a hearing to be scheduled.
We are working with the local grassroots group, Hawai‘i Death with Dignity Society, to re-build a foundation for success in 2017.
Note: This page includes edited versions of various texts by Eli D. Stutsman, JD, and Scott Foster.