RSSHigh Court Decision Leaves Assisted Suicide Issue Where it Belongs: With the States
By None, The Monitor (Texas), Jan. 20, 2006
Editorial
America's constitutional system limits federal control over state actions. That means people in one state may not like actions taken by the people of another state, yet still have to respect the other state's actions on a range of issues.
That's why the U.S. Supreme Court on Jan. 17 was right not to overturn an Oregon law, passed by voters in a 1994 initiative, that allows physician-assisted suicide.
Writing for the 6-3 majority in the Gonzales v. Oregon case, Justice Anthony Kennedy pointed to "the structure and limitations of federalism." He quoted from a previous Supreme Court decision in the 1996 case Medtronic Inc. v. Lohr, which said the states have "great latitude under their police powers to legislate as to the protection of the lives, limbs, health, comfort, and quiet of all persons."
In 1992, we opposed an initiative, defeated by voters, that would have allowed assisted suicide in California. We were concerned that healers not become those who take life in the fashion of Dr. Jack Kevorkian, the pathologist currently imprisoned in Michigan on a murder conviction in an assisted-suicide case.
A more recent concern is that Oregon — or California — could become like the Netherlands, where assisted suicide (in which the patient is enabled to take a deadly action) seems to be leading to legalized euthanasia (in which a doctor directly kills the patient). The Dutch now have what they call "ending life without the explicit request of the patient." Although still illegal, it is winked at in practice.
Unfortunately, the Supreme Court decision has given new life to a bill introduced in the California Legislature last year, but not passed, that would legalize assisted suicide in this state. AB651 is by Assemblywoman Patty Berg, D-Eureka. She told the Jan. 18 San Francisco Chronicle that the decision provides an opportunity "to re-look at this bill." Let's hope not.
But the Supreme Court at least has left the matter in the hands of the states, where it belongs.
As to Oregon, those opposing its assisted-suicide law can take the matter up with the citizens of that state.
Share on StumbleUpon
Defend dignity. Take action.
For more than 14 years, the Death with Dignity National Center (DDNC), a 501(c)(3), non-partisan, non-profit organization, has been the leading advocate in the death with dignity movement. Leaders in our organization originally wrote and have continued advocating for the Oregon Death with Dignity Law. DDNC has met these challenges through extensive legal defense of the Oregon law, education and outreach programs, and by developing and nurturing diverse financial resources with one goal in mind: to ensure DDNC's financial vitality and its position as a leader in the death with dignity movement.
Your donation today will enable us to continue to advocate for the right of the terminally ill to die with dignity. Please click here to give a secure, online donation. Thank you.
Get Email Updates
Sign up for the latest news, blogs, and action alerts in the fight for Death with Dignity.
Political Action Fund
The Death with Dignity National Center partners with the Oregon Death with Dignity Political Action Fund (the Fund) to conduct lobbying and political activities in order to achieve the enactment of Death with Dignity laws in other states. The partnership resulted in tremendous success with the resounding win in the 2008 Washington Death with Dignity campaign.
Learn more about the Fund's efforts to bring dignity to people around the nation.
About Death with Dignity
The greatest human freedom is to live, and die, according to one's own desires and beliefs. The most common desire among those with a terminal illness is to die with some measure of dignity. From advance directives to physician-assisted dying, death with dignity is a movement to provide options for the dying to control their own end-of-life care.
Death with Dignity National Center (DDNC) is the leader in this movement, successfully establishing, advancing and defending the landmark Oregon Death with Dignity Act -- a national catalyst for openly discussing and actively reforming end-of-life care for those who are terminally ill.
Learn more about the National Center and our family of organizations.
Patients & Families
The Death with Dignity National Center was formed out of a profound commitment to the idea that personal end-of-life decisions should be made solely between a patient and a physician. Based on this commitment, we are pleased to provide you with support and information as you face the difficult challenges ahead.
Research Center
We have compiled a comprehensive collection of legal briefs, journal articles, and newspaper clippings. We invite you to explore the wide array of information we have collected throughout our history.
In our Research Center you will find frequently asked questions, the history of the death with dignity movement, state monitoring statistics, and a copy of this groundbreaking statute.
